Mayors
Village Presidents
| 1846 | Sutherland, Thomas |
| 1847-1849 | Collins, A.L. |
| 1850 | Seymour, William N. (1808-1886) |
| 1851 | Mills, Simeon (1810-6/1/1895) |
| 1852 | Abbott, Chauncey (9/16/1815-1/30/1872) |
| 1853 | Tenney, Horace A. (2/22/1820-3/13/1906) |
| 1854 | Mills, Simeon (1810-6/1/1895) |
| 1855 | Van Bergen, Peter (1809-1/22/1879) |
Mayors
| 1856 | Fairchild, Jairus C. (12/27/1801-7/18/1862) |
| 1857 | Bird, Augustus A. (1802-1870) |
| 1858-1860 | Smith, George B. (5/22/1823-9/18/1879) |
| 1861 | Vilas, Levi B. (2/25/1811-2/6/1879) |
| 1860-1864 | Leitch, William T. (1808-1885) |
| 1865-1866 | Keyes, Elisha W. (1/23/1828-11/29/1910) |
| 1867 | Sanborn, Alden Sprague (10/21/1820-11/17/1885) |
| 1868 | Atwood, David (12/15/1815-12/11/1889) |
| 1869-1870 | Proudfit, Andrew (8/3/1820-11/12/1883) |
| 1871 | Bowen, James Barton (8/19/1815-8/27/1881) |
| 1872 | Hill, James L. (1834-1888) |
| 1873 | Gregory, Jared Comstock (1/13/1828-2/17/1892) |
| 1874-1875 | Pinney, Silas U. (3/3/1833-4/1/1899) |
| 1876 | Jones, John N. (1817-1898) |
| 1877 | Orton, Harlow S. (11/23/1817-7/4/1895) |
| 1878 | Smith, George B. (5/22/1823-9/18/1879) |
| 1879 | Baltzell, John R. (7/2/1827-7/18/1893) |
| 1880 | Spooner, Jr., Philip L. (1/13/1847-1/2/1918) |
| 1881-1883 | Conklin, James (6/12/1831-2/27/1899) |
| 1884 | Stevens, Breese J. (1834-10/28/1903) |
| 1885 | Moulton, Hiram N. (8/14/1818-8/28/1899) |
| 1886 | Keyes, Elisha W. (1/23/1828-11/29/1910) |
| 1887 | Conklin, James (6/12/1831-2/27/1899) |
| 1888-1889 | Doyon, Moses Ransom (12/18/1845-8/12/1933) |
| 1890 | Bashford, Robert McKee (12/31/1845-1/29/1911) |
| 1891-1892 | Rogers, William H. (3/15/1850-11/26/1935) |
| 1893-1894 | Corscot, John H. (9/12/1839-5/13/1926) |
| 1895 | Alford, Jabe B. (9/21/1850-9/10/1927) |
| 1896 | Dye, Albert A. (1845-1934) |
| 1897 | Hoven, Mathias J. (7/9/1850-10/1/1901) |
| 1898 | Whelan, Charles Elbert (8/26/1862-11/29/1928) |
| 1899-1900 | Hoven, Mathias J. (7/9/1850-10/1/1901) |
| 1901 | Bull, Storm (10/20/1856-11/17/1907) |
| 1902-1903 | Goves, John W. (1844-12/4/1921) |
| 1904-1905 | Curtis, William Dexter (7/4/1857-12/19/1935) |
| 1906-1911 | Schubert, Joseph C. (1/9/1871-11/10/1959) |
| 1912-1913 | Heim, John B. (7/15/1848-11/2/1919) |
| 1914-1915 | Kayser, Adolph H. (1/28/1851-1/26/1925) |
| 1916-1919 | Sayle, George C. (1864-1951) |
| 1920-1925 | Kittleson, Isaac Milo (11/17/1874-4/2/1958) |
| 1926-1932 | Schmedeman, Sr., Albert G. (11/25/1864-11/26/1946) |
| 1932-1943 | Law, Jr., James R. (4/1/1885-3/14/1952) |
| 1943-1947 | Kraege, Fred Halsey (5/3/1899-5/12/1982)* |
| 1947-1950 | Howell, Leonard G. (1894-1980)** |
| 1950-1955 | Forster, George J. (7/26/1905-11/17/1988) |
| 1955-1956 | Bareis, Alfred W. (5/17/1893-8/7/1976) |
| 1956-1961 | Nestingen, Ivan A. (9/9/1921-4/24/1978) |
| 1961 interim | Hanson, Harol E. (1895-11/29/1978) |
| 1961-1965 | Reynolds, Henry Edward (12/5/1905-11/2/1980) |
| 1965-1969 | Festge, Otto (1921-2007) |
| 1969-1973 | Dyke, William (1931- ) |
| 1973-1979 | Soglin, Paul R. (1945 - ) |
| 1979-1983 | Skornicka, Joel (1937 - ) |
| 1983-1989 | Sensenbrenner, Jr., F. Joseph (1949 - ) |
| 1989-1997 | Soglin, Paul R. (1945 - ) |
| 1997-2003 | Baumann, Susan J.M. (1945 - ) |
| 2003-2011 | Cieslewicz, Dave (1959 - ) |
| 2011-present | Soglin, Paul R. (1945 - ) |
*Mayor, Acting City Manager
**City Manager